Real world assessment

in a lot of situations as a 3d artist I would assume that you the designer would be the one making the models of the room / building. In this situation you said that you did the site assessment. did you take all these measurements yourself and mark the exact places that you got the measurements? I'm trying to put together how in depth a site assessor would measure each wall and area because I'm used to being told the total length width and height, occasionally on both the top and bottom of the wall but often its assumed to be uniform by anyone I've gotten measurements from and then we have to adjust the installation to fit... in larger companies I assume you'd have someone else than the designer go in to do the assessment and potentially someone else who would draw the plans in another software who might not account for the imperfections. If that end up with the measurements not being detailed enough to show the bumps and inconsistent angles and imperfections then how do you design and model to compensate for it?? for example the top and bottom difference on the right wall of 8mm, would you model from building plans or documents from the construction of the wall or would you manually go in and measure the depth in 5 places like shown in the vid? Are there any industry standards to the measurements that you base your whole model from or would you have clients that sometimes you need to trust the documentation on and then adjust on site when it inevitably doesn't fit?
1 love
Reply
  • Omar Domenech replied

    I don't know in Germany, but in my country people just wing it. There aren't really too much real professionals here. Also I see architects use a little device with a laser that takes very precise measurements, people probably use that. 

    2 loves
  • Sascha Feider replied

    Hi Sam,

    let me try and take your question apart a bit.
    In this case, as with all my projects for my clients, I did go in and take all those measurements myself. As the one who not only designs the project, but also builds it, I want to have as many measurements as possible. How many it end up being, is different from site to site.
    After a visual inspection the first thing I usually do is throw a long level at the wall and see what I'm working with. From there I then look at what the idea for the project is and how that correlates with the measurements I need. With that in mind I then decide how many measurements to take.
    Of course there will always be the need for adjustments on site during installation. It's one of the reasons for trim panels on the sides. There's many variable that can play into this, like slight differences in material thickness and cut tolerances for example.
    That's the case when designing and building. And I never, ever rely on client's dimension.

    Now let's assume you're just a designer and are given the measurements, be it from someone in a company you work at, or someone else who just needs a design.
    Ideally again the measurements are as detailed as possible. Especially when taken by a professional site assessor, you should be able to rely on it. At least if they're doing their job right. During the design process you should still compensate for possible inconsistencies, but again that's where trim comes in.
    The responsibility for the fit in such a case should never be on the designer. In this case the designer is just the person who makes it look good. Whoever takes the measurements and builds it, is responsible to a) give you the right information and b) make sure that the design fits the site.

    There's no real industry standard on how many measurements you should take. As mentioned it should be at least top and bottom width, depth in two to three places and height too. But it all depends on the site and the project.

    Hope this helps. 🙂

    Omar: No, Germans don't wing it. Too pedantic. I should know, I used to be one. 😁

    2 loves
  • Sam Edgar(AngelAzrael) replied

    Very helpful information thanks! 

    2 loves