Boolean looks to be working in wire frame not in solid

CGC Modeling Challenges

bool2.pngbool1.pngbool3.pngbool4.png

1 love
Reply
  • Martin Bergwerf replied

    Hi DDeadmanstroll ,

    Love the addition of the screenshots, but it's not clear to me, what they mean here, without context.

    Could you add a Timestamp and tell us what Lesson this is in (I know what Course, but you don't even mention that).

    1 love
  • Deadmanstroll replied
    yes sorry about that, actually i am showing that i wanted to make a cut out using two small rectangle box 2nd image is the box i am using for boolean, 1st image shows that applying boolean makes a cut out of the box in wireframe, but if you can see in 3rd image the boolen isn't working in solid mode, and 4th image to show there isnt any double mesh so not sure why its not working, ps - in 2nd image i have used boolean at the side too to make curve cut out for the knob that seems to be working overall.
    1 love
  • Deadmanstroll replied
    i have completed my core modelling course so i am not following the modelling part of the course and doing it myself. will follow up from texturing part so no timestamp. :(
    1 love
  • Martin Bergwerf replied

    Hi DDeadmanstroll ,

    Right, that cleared those screenshots up for me, thank you.

    Still, I don't know exactly what's going on. Booleans are very finnicky, but a difference between Solid and Wireframe is weird. Maybe a Face that is Hidden (in Edit Mode), that is covering the holes? Far-fetched, I know.

    If you could upload your .blend (Dropbox, Googledrive, or so) and post a link here, we can have a look.

    2 loves
  • Adrian Bellworthy replied

    Hey,

    The Boolean Cutter objects should be hidden in the viewport, I can see in the outliner the objects named Bool1 and Bool2 are hidden in image 1, 3 and 4, but in image 2 they are not. You'll want to disable them in the viewport (eye) and render (camera).

    Also I would suggest renaming objects as soon as you add them, you seem to have quite a few objects named cube and cylinder, anyone of these could be a duplicate Boolean cutter added in error.

    2 loves
  • Deadmanstroll replied

    hello, i tried all suggested way nothing worked here is the file link please can you guys check it and see whats wrong - https://drive.google.com/file/d/1xOQOHGhW4o4Tue8H4U5mDIx7u4u1nf-R/view?usp=drive_link

    1 love
  • Adrian Bellworthy replied

    I'm not entirely sure why it wasn't working, but deleting the bool cutter object and re-adding a new one solved the issue.

    2 loves
  • Martin Bergwerf replied
    Solution

    Hi DDeadmanstroll ,

    It's a classic: wrong Normals:

    Camera_00.png

    Flip the Normals of the Boolean Cutters and:

    cAMERA_01.png

    I hope that it goes without saying, that you should fix the other Normals as well. And as Adrian already pointed out before: name your Objects!

    • 💯🎯
    2 loves
  • Deadmanstroll replied

    hey it worked wonders thanks Adrian thanks Martin, yes ill also make a habit to name them properly will help in long term, thanks

    • 👍
    1 love
  • Grady Pruitt(gradyp) replied

    In addition to making things easier to use in this project, it makes them much easier if you go back and look at a file later and/or want to link/append something from this project in the future. :D

    1 love