
When I added the Plastic Orange color, it did not seem to select the screen and speakers section of the console mesh. See above.
Hi Cara
MothVolka ,
What happens if you remove you second Material Slot:

If nothing changes when you do that, that would mean your Screen and Speakers are Separate Objects from the Console (maybe just Parented).
Deleting that second Material Slot did not fix it, but I was able to do a workaround by just selecting the seperate faces and applying the materials by hand. Thank you everyone for your feedback!